PHRF-LO Toronto East Summer Meeting Minutes 2010
June 1st, 2010
Jamie Dike – FBYC
Colin Alston – FBYC
Rob Lenters – COYC
Vic Coram – HYC
Sandpiper 565 MOD;
Discussion of Applications lost found and submitted.
Discussion on Forum reviewed and taken into account.
After Review of the MODs Rating Confirmed with Base SP’s FS 294 NFS 312 No -6 to protect the fleet as it was felt to be unstable.
C&C 35 MK 2MOD
Discussion of reality of +6 for Asymmetrical conversions.
Rating Confirmed with Base SP’s Fs132 NFS144 -6 to protect the fleet (due to disagreement with central council or conversion penalties and bonuses) Final rating SP FS 126 NFS 138 (Due to -6 PTF Penalty cannot be applied to just FS of NFS even if the MOD only applies to one).
Votes from Forum Taken into account.
Bavaria 33 SD
Review of design with interest in shell keel on the SD version (only the SD version rated) Discussion on Forum reviewed and taken into account. After Review of the MODs Rating Confirmed with Base SP’s FS 156 NFS 174 not including the-6 to protect the fleet as required by central council meeting March 2010. Final Base Sp’s FS150 NFS 168. Note that the Club it belongs to is rating it for internal racing at FS 198 and it is not performing.
Note from District;
Request for CC to review the +6 Bonus for boats converting from Symmetrical spinnaker to Asymmetrical Spinnaker for ‘Sober Second Thought “on account of Potential Benefits to MOD boats. Handicappers at the meeting felt the conversion will not be as big a detriment as the rating rule reflects.
Meeting Adjourned 2000hrs.
Jamie Dike TORE District Chief